The 7 Pitfalls of Pay for Performance SEO & What You Should Do Instead

It can be pretty easy to feel overwhelmed and look for helpful shortcuts in the complex landscape of digital marketing. Searching for a pay-for-performance SEO company might seem like an easy solution to your problems.

It's an enticing proposition that promises high rankings on search engines like Google, seemingly mitigating risk by ensuring you only pay when specific results are delivered. But is it truly as advantageous as it appears?

We're going to dissect the seven potential pitfalls of pay-for-performance SEO and suggest more reliable alternatives that legitimately elevate your online visibility.

The Difference Between Pay for Performance SEO and Traditional SEO

Pay-for-performance SEO is a digital marketing strategy where you only pay when specific results are achieved. Think of it as a results-based contract between you and an SEO agency or freelancer (and check out our freelance contract template if needed).

SEO agencies offering a performance-based SEO model are most attractive to business owners who have a tight budget, limited time, or a limited understanding of how to run an SEO campaign.

The promise of pay-for-performance SEO is improved search engine rankings. That means when someone types in keywords related to your business, your website appears higher up in the search results.

While results may vary, here are some of the deliverables that performance-based SEO agencies offer:

• Keyword Research
• On-Page SEO
• Off-Page SEO
• Reporting

A traditional SEO campaign, on the other hand, requires an upfront cost to develop and execute the strategy. A traditional SEO agency will research your business goals and objectives, define a target audience and set up campaigns to drive organic website traffic or revenue.

Remember, while pay-for-performance SEO might sound appealing due to its results-based nature, it's essential to choose a reputable provider. Some agencies might use black hat SEO tactics to deliver quick results, which could harm your website in the long run.

Pitfalls of Pay for Performance SEO

It's important to understand the potential traps associated with pay-for-performance SEO. While many of the benefits of this search engine optimization model are attractive, bear in mind that it's not always the best choice.

Here are 7 of the most common challenges associated with pay-for-performance SEO:

1. Low-Quality Backlinks

A backlink is a link from another website to yours. However, not all types of backlinks are equal.

Low-quality backlinks from irrelevant or spammy websites can harm your SEO. Harmful backlinks often include:

• Unrelated industries
• Spammy blog comments
• Paid links
• Links from sites with poor domain authority

Pay-for-performance SEO companies may sometimes form relationships with these low-quality sites to quickly generate backlinks. This practice, which often involves purchasing links, can lead to penalties, harming your site's rankings in the long term.

2. Targeting Keywords Without Traffic

Many pay-for-performance SEO companies prioritize the wrong keywords (make sure you know what to look for in an SEO company). This often means targeting keywords with little or no search volume.

These SEO agencies also target vanity keywords, which are terms that don't actually relate to your business but technically may rank.

The problem is that these keywords aren't relevant to your target audience, so they won't lead to actual conversions. Many SEO agencies may charge for these types of keywords since they tend to be easier and quicker to rank for.

This leaves you in the weeds when it comes to achieving your business goals since you're not targeting the right users.

The solution? Make sure your agency focuses on long-tail keywords that have higher search volume and are more relevant to your target market.

3. Focusing On Just One SEO Factor

SEO is a complex process that requires a comprehensive approach. Focusing solely on one aspect, such as ranking keywords, can lead to underwhelming results.

Some Pay for Performance SEO agencies may narrow their focus to this area, neglecting other crucial factors.

In order to cultivate sustainable search engine results, it's important to focus on the following factors:

• Bounce Rate: The percentage of visitors who navigate away from your site after viewing just one page.
• Click-Through Rate (CTR): CTR assesses how often people click on your website after it appears in search results.
• Site Speed: Slow-loading pages can deter visitors and negatively influence your search engine rankings.

Ignoring these components can limit the effectiveness of your SEO strategy. The best SEO agencies use a balanced, holistic approach that takes several SEO factors into account.

4. Inaccurate Measuring of Results

In digital marketing, particularly in SEO, accurately measuring results is critical to understanding the effectiveness of your strategies. However, a common mistake made by some agencies or marketers is reporting on single aspects of the campaign without considering others.

These shady SEO tactics can lead to a skewed understanding of the campaign's success and are one of the major pitfalls of pay-for-performance SEO.

Good performance-based agencies measure results by taking into account several factors, such as:

• Traffic Increase: How many people are visiting your website?
• Keywords Rankings: What keywords are you ranking for?
• Conversion Rate: How often do visitors convert into leads or customers?

For instance, an agency might focus solely on keyword rankings, touting the number of first-page results achieved. While this is a relevant metric, it shouldn't be the only one used.

5. Low-Quality Writing Due to Keyword Stuffing

Keyword stuffing is an outdated SEO tactic that involves overloading a webpage's content with target keywords in an attempt to manipulate a site's ranking on Google's search result pages. This strategy not only results in low-quality writing but also negatively impacts the user experience and can harm your site's SEO.

Let's say you run a bakery and want to rank for "best chocolate cake." A keyword-stuffed paragraph might read like this:

"Are you looking for the best chocolate cake? Our bakery offers the best chocolate cake in town. You won't find a better chocolate cake anywhere else. Come try our best chocolate cake and taste the difference."

As you can see, this paragraph sounds unnatural and repetitive because of the overuse of the phrase "best chocolate cake." It doesn't provide valuable information to the reader and could turn potential customers away.

Google and other search engines have evolved to prioritize high-quality content that provides value to users. They use complex algorithms that can detect keyword stuffing and will penalize websites that engage in this practice.

Penalties can range from lower rankings on search results to complete de-indexation, depending on the severity of the offense.

6. Short Term Goal Horizons and Relationships

The benefit of hiring a performance-based SEO agency is to speed up results; speed isn't always the most useful factor.

Short-term goal horizons often involve an attempt for immediate gains, such as:

• Increasing blog posts for a particular quarter
• Boosting website traffic by a dramatic amount within a month
• Getting a certain number of sign-ups for a newsletter within a week

While these are valid objectives, they can sometimes lead to strategies that prioritize immediate results over long-term success.

Agencies that seem too good to be true may resort to aggressive SEO services, which can ultimately damage the brand's success and the overall goals of the SEO campaign.

7. Unnatural Over Optimization

Over-optimization in SEO occurs when a website is excessively tweaked or manipulated with the sole aim of improving its search engine rankings, often at the expense of the user experience or adherence to SEO best practices.

Here are some examples of unnatural over-optimization in SEO campaigns:

• Fake Social Signals: SEO services might resort to buying likes, shares, or followers on social media platforms to give the impression of high engagement and popularity. However, these are often from bot accounts and do not drive traffic to sites or improve rankings.
• Too Many Internal Links: While internal linking is an essential part of SEO, excessive linking can also confuse search engine crawlers about the most important pages on your website. This dilutes the value of truly important links.
• Anchor Text Over-Optimization: This involves using the exact match keywords too frequently as the anchor text for links. Overdoing it can make your site look spammy to search engines.
• Low-Quality External Links: Building a large number of low-quality backlinks (links from low-authority or irrelevant websites) can harm your site's SEO. Search engines prioritize the quality of links over quantity, so it's better to have fewer but more relevant and high-quality links.

Unnatural over-optimization can lead to penalties from search engines and a poor user experience, both of which can harm your site's visibility and reputation in the long run.

What to Do Instead of Pay for Performance SEO

It can be challenging to set up a long-term SEO campaign when performance-based SEO may not deliver the desired results. But there are plenty of things you can do on your own or find a reputable SEO agency to help you with.

Here are three tips to keep in mind:

Use Quality Links and Content

Prioritize creating valuable, high-quality content that naturally incorporates your target keywords. This means avoiding vanity keywords, keyword stuffing, and using irrelevant terms.

Similarly, focus on building natural, meaningful links from reputable, relevant websites. The more authoritative and relevant the website that links to your content, the more powerful it will be for your SEO model.

Focus on Multiple SEO Factors Simultaneously

SEO involves a multitude of factors, including:

• On-page optimization (keywords, meta tags, content)
• Off-page optimization (backlinks, social signals)
• Technical SEO (site speed, mobile-friendliness).

A comprehensive approach that addresses all these aspects will yield more sustainable results than a narrow focus on one element.

Choose a Reputable SEO Agency

Choosing a reputable SEO agency can drastically affect your website's visibility and overall online success. There are plenty of affordable SEO services for small businesses that can help with keyword rankings and first-page rankings.

It's crucial to consider factors such as the agency's track record, client testimonials, and expertise in various SEO aspects, including local or e-commerce SEO services.

Here are a few of the best SEO agencies that produce long-lasting results for their clients:

• BrandBuilders provides premium SEO content writing services, optimizing your content for search engines while ensuring it's engaging for your audience, as well as site management services. Learn more in our BrandBuilders review!
• The HOTH offers a range of SEO services, including link building, content creation, and local SEO.
• SEOButler offers comprehensive SEO and content solutions for marketers, including keyword research, on-page optimization, and quality link building.

Check out The Hoth review for more information on the agency and its services. Take time to research an agency before signing up, and don't be afraid to ask questions.

Remember, the best SEO agency for your needs will depend on your specific goals, budget, and the level of involvement you want in the SEO process. So choose wisely!

Final Thoughts: Pay for Performance SEO

While performance-based SEO may seem appealing due to its results-oriented approach, it's crucial to understand the importance of sustainable, long-term SEO strategies.

Choosing a reputable SEO agency that aligns with your business goals and adheres to SEO best practices is key.

Whichever approach you choose, make sure to focus on creating quality content and building meaningful links. Remember, if it looks too good to be true, it probably is!

Related Posts

What is the Average SEO Cost? Tips to Plan Your Spending

13 Best Websites to Help You Get High-Quality SEO Leads

Website Architecture: 9 Proven Tips to Boost Your SEO Success

How to Find Expired Domains and Boost Your Website’s Success

What to Look for in an SEO Company: 7 Agency Attributes That Matter Most